Welcome to Sarah's Pizza
"Sarah's Pizza, located in West Alexandria, OH, is a hidden gem serving up delicious pizzas with a unique twist. Customers rave about the mashed potato pizza and generous toppings on specialty pies like the Greek pizza. The small-town charm adds to the dining experience, with friendly staff and quick service. As a regular, I appreciate the great deals and consistently amazing pizza. From classic pepperoni to creative options like bacon double cheeseburger and taco pizza, Sarah's Pizza never disappoints. Don't miss out on their cheesy breadsticks and savory subs – they are a must-try. Overall, Sarah's Pizza is a favorite among locals and visitors alike for its exceptional food and welcoming atmosphere."
-
77 E Dayton St West Alexandria, OH 4538177 E Dayton St West Alexandria, OH 45381 Hotline: (937) 839-5499
Welcome to Sarah's Pizza, a hidden gem located at 77 E Dayton St in West Alexandria, OH. This women-owned pizza joint offers a wide range of options for pizza lovers, from classic pepperoni to unique creations like mashed potato pizza and bacon double cheeseburger pizza. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, Sarah's Pizza is the perfect spot for group gatherings, family dinners, or even a quiet meal for one.
One of the standout dishes that customers rave about is the mashed potato pizza, which has become a crowd favorite. The generous toppings and flavorful combinations make each bite a delightful experience. Pair your pizza with some cheesy breadsticks or a deluxe pizza sub for a complete meal that will leave you satisfied.
Customers appreciate the variety of options available, as well as the convenience of delivery and takeout services. The staff at Sarah's Pizza is friendly and efficient, ensuring that your order is ready in a timely manner. Whether you're a local regular or just passing through town, Sarah's Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers of all kinds.
So next time you're in West Alexandria, don't miss out on the opportunity to try the delicious offerings at Sarah's Pizza. With excellent customer reviews and a loyal following, this pizza joint is sure to become a favorite spot for anyone who appreciates good food and friendly service.
Highly recommend this place. We got pizza for a party of 80. Stephanie and the crew were great and very helpful. The pizzas were ready when they promised! The mashed potato pizza was loved by most of the group! Thanks again!!
Good pizza, had a cheese and a mashed potato pizza, decent specialty list to choose from
Good pizza, pleasant staff working. Had the Greek and Mashed potato. Generous on the toppings. Many sizes to choose from.
Don't forget to support you favorite places during the pandemic. We got some carry out from Sarah's and it was awesome! Ordered and paid over the phone then went to pick up. The process was simplistic as calling a number when you got there and they brought your pizza right out. Our favorite is absolutely the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It was definitely a nice escape to have some good ole hometown comfort food! Keep up the good work.
Sarah's Pizza has some of my favorite pizza, hands down. I always ask for extra sauce, because it's just so good, and I can't get enough. I've never had a bad pizza there. I love the classic pepperoni, but they have some amazing speciality pizzas as well, including their bacon double cheeseburger pizza, taco pizza, and mashed potato pizza. Sarah's also has an AMAZING spaghetti dinner: a huge portion of baked spaghetti and meatballs with their amazing marinara sauce topped with a thick layer of melted cheese and served with garlic bread. Subs are also great, along with their hot wings, huge burgers, and cheese sticks. Sarah's is a forever staple in our house.
Great little Pizza place that you will drive right past and not even see (no sign out front). I am guessing that the locals don't need the sign Pizza is great and was ready in 10 minutes. Thanks again.
Eat here once a week it seems. Great deals and awesome pizza. I eat a lot of pizza all over and Sarah is still my favorite. Cheese sticks are a for sure addition to any dinner and their subs are great as well.
I LOVE this pizza. I've yet to find pizza that I truly dislike... but in a tiny town like West Alex, it's nice to have a pizza joint with AMAZING pizza. I tend to get the same few menu items but they've always been phenomenal. The pizza, cheese sticks, and deluxe pizza subs are my favorite. SO, SO good. The prices are decent -- and right now on Mondays and Tuesdays, they have super cheap deals. Medium pizza for $6, pizza subs for $4. My boyfriend and I order food from Sarah's atleast once a week, sometimes twice. I've always done take out or delivery. They're super fast either way and everyone on staff is super friendly. It's 10 am and I'm already thinking I should order Sarah's for dinner tonight.
I've been going to Sarah's for years now. All of their food is great! It has that small business feel, and that makes it a great place. I would recommend this place the whole time - even over the big guys (Donato's, Pizza Hut, etc.)